• Banner 3
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 1

Welcome to Keyport Fishery

Keyport Fishery, located in Keyport, NJ, is a seafood market offering a delightful variety of fresh seafood dishes and fish & chips. With a focus on quality and freshness, this local gem has been serving satisfied customers since the 1930s. The menu boasts favorites like fried seafood platters, fish sandwiches, and shrimp meals that keep patrons coming back for more. Despite its humble setting and cash-only policy, Keyport Fishery's simple yet delicious offerings and waterfront views make it a beloved spot for seafood lovers. Don't miss out on their must-try scallops and fried fish - a true Jersey gem worth savoring.

Keyport Fishery: Reviews & Ratings

Victoria T.
Victoria T.

The BEST fried seafood in the world!!!!! So fresh and delicious, Once you receive your order, it's like torture having to smell that delicious fried seafood before you get to actually eat it!!!! Mmm, mmm, mmm!!!!

Teresa W.
Teresa W.

Go there at least 2x a month. Food is great. Service is good. Very busy place!!!!! There fried shrimp sandwich is super. Love there tarter sauce. I think It is time to go back again !!!!!

Stephen M.
Stephen M.

"No fish for you!" If you wish the soup nazi sold fish, you're in luck. This is the kind of place people still go to despite the horrible cranky attitudes and gruff "stand here, pay there, hurry up give us your money and get lost" type attitudes. These guys print money by the hour but you're basically on your own. Gotta give it a 4 out of sheer freshness and quality.

Dan M.
Dan M.

Great fresh fried fish. It's the best in the state. Nice casual atmosphere. Quick service.

Joy Y.
Joy Y.

Honestly one of my favorite local places to order from. The seafood is fresh and the entrees are so simple but delicious. The softshell crab does go fast so i recommend going before the dinner rush on weekends. Even if theres a long line, it moves pretty quickly. Its cash only! But they have an ATM inside if you forget. I love that its right by the water so you can enjoy your meal right there. I usually get the scallops platter and theyre so soft and juicy. Theyre not overly breaded either.

B P.
B P.

Never disappoints! my friend loves the scallops and i get that just for her whenever i can as she's wheelchair bound. Service is fast and staff is always courteous. It's takeout & cash only! on the water of course beautiful!

Ed M.
Ed M.

Really good fish cakes and fries. The tartar sauce was on point. A great location to sit out front and enjoy the food and weather. We will return to purchase some fresh seafood as it looked really good.

Brendan B.
Brendan B.

What is not to love about Keyport fishery! Very old school style fishery where you can order takeout or fresh seafood from the market. I always get a good meal every time I go in there whether it's a fish sandwich, fried scallops or shrimp it is always delicious and fresh! Fries are always on point too. Great nautical fishery feel inside and the staff is always helpful and gets you in and out of there in minutes. On a nice day you can grab your fresh seafood takeout and go sit in the marina for a beautiful view with your meal or even if it's not so nice out you can sit in your car in the marina and still enjoy the view. Been going to the Keyport fishery for years. It has survived many hurricanes and has been a staple in the community for a very long time!

Sam C.
Sam C.

I have been going to Keyport Fishery since the mid-60s. And my Dad went there an entire generation before. It is so good, words can't describe. This place is a Jersey gem, a kind of local secret, it is so good. When you try to describe how good it is, it is hard, because folks will think you are exaggerating. I have eaten fish in some very fancy restaurants. Keyport Fishery is not only as good, not only better, but is simply the best fish I have ever had. The scallops are a must. You can start with the combo platter. Just go. Just try one scallop. You will be hooked...for life! Oh, it is all take-out. Do what the locals do. We park in the parking lot across the street and eat the treasure, sitting right on the bay! This place has been there since 1930 or something. There is a reason...

Latha P.
Latha P.

Fried food has a bad rap but it's so satisfying to eat ! This is a to cash only place and they serve fresh fried everything seafood . Walk in to a rather small fishy smelling storefront that was l packed , look up their long menu displayed and order your meal . We went easy and ordered the Louisiana crab soup and shrimp & Scallop meal with fries and coleslaw . Not very crispy yet golfers fried goodness with toast inside sweet form the natural flavor of scallops and shrimp . Side of cri kept cut fries wasn't crispy as expected but it was still good . The tartar sauce and coleslaw were top of line traditional simple No frills attached ! The soup was a tomato broth based and has no seafood smell but good crab chunks and flavor. You have to take your meal to your car and eat which is the only challenge( if you see it that way )! We were aware and were ok with eating in our car with a lovely view of the waterfront on a warm day . Perfect setting for a non greasy fried meal . The inside wasn't very appealing but they are not marketing their place as anything fancy so it's perfectly ok. It's self service and food is ready fast so no complaints there either . Good fried seafood at affordable prices and fresh catch to take home is their offering . I would recommend this to anyone who is up for the adventure.

Location

Keyport Fishery is a seafood market located in Keyport, New Jersey, that offers a variety of seafood dishes, including fish and chips. This establishment is known for its fresh and delicious fried seafood, as mentioned by Victoria T. in her review. Customers like Teresa W. frequent the place for their great food and service, especially enjoying the fried shrimp sandwich. Despite some reviews mentioning a brusque atmosphere, the quality and freshness of the seafood keep people coming back for more.

One standout dish that customers rave about is the scallops platter, described as soft and juicy by Joy Y. and B P. The seafood offerings are simple yet delicious, with options like fish cakes and fries impressing customers like Ed M. and Brendan B. Keyport Fishery has been a local favorite for generations, with loyal customers like Sam C. praising it as the best fish they have ever had.

The menu at Keyport Fishery includes a variety of seafood options, all prepared fresh to order. From staples like fried shrimp and scallops to specialties like Louisiana crab soup, there is something for every seafood lover to enjoy. The casual atmosphere, quick service, and beautiful waterfront location make it a perfect spot to grab a meal and enjoy the views.

For those looking for a no-frills, authentic seafood experience, Keyport Fishery is a must-visit. The combination of friendly service, fresh ingredients, and classic seafood dishes make it a staple in the community. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely meal by the water, Keyport Fishery offers a taste of the sea that keeps customers coming back time and time again.